Insurance Carrier Contacts
To make changes to your policy or ask coverage questions, please contact us at 201-659-2403.
Need to get in touch with your insurance company directly? See below for the contact information of all the companies we represent.
Licensed in Over 30 States
AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.
877-528-7878
AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.
59 Maiden Lane
New York, NY 10038
Phone: 212-220-7120
Fax: 212-220-7130
Andover – Baystate & Merrimack
(978) 475-3300
(800) 225-0770
The Andover Companies
95 Old River Rd.
Andover, MA 01810
Chubb / Great Northern / Vigilant & Federal
Cumberland Mutual Insurance Co.
EMAIL: guestservices@cumberlandfarms.com
MAILING ADDRESS:
Cumberland Farms, Inc., 165 Flanders Road, Westborough, MA 01581
Farmers Mutual of Salem
(800) 498-0954
ADDRESS:
PHYSICAL ADDRESS:
125 WEST BROADWAY
SALEM, NJ 08079
MAILING ADDRESS:
PO BOX 263
SALEM, NJ 08079
BUSINESS HOURS:
MONDAY – FRIDAY
8:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Foremost Insurance Company Group
1-800-527-3905
Monday – Friday, 9 AM to 8 PM ET
Foremost AARP Service Center:
1-800-752-2461
Monday – Friday, 8:30 AM to 10 PM and
Saturday, 9 AM to 5 PM ET
Foremost Direct Service Center:
1-800-237-2060
Monday – Friday, 8:30 AM to 10 PM and
Saturday, 9 AM to 5 PM ET
Franklin Mutual Insurance Company / FMI Co
PO Box 400
Branchville, NJ 07826
Phone (800) 336-3642
Fax (973) 948-7190
Lemonade
How can I reach you?
If you have a Lemonade policy or have had one in the past and need help now, click here to get started. Otherwise, you can always get in touch with our team through our app or website.
Lemonade has a network of emergency response and repair partners enabling us to respond to just about any incident at just about any time.
For emergencies relating to your car, home, and property where you don’t have access to our app or website, you may call us at (844) 733-8666.
To reach Lemonade about a car claim via email you may contact us at carclaims@lemonade.com
Narragansett
National General
Ask about your policy, including payments & coverage changes:
Auto: 888-293-5108
Home: 888-325-1190
Fitchburg Mutual / Norfolk & Dedham
1-800-688-1825
Email: customerservice@ndgroup.com
Address
222 Ames Street, P.O.Box 9109 Dedham, MA 02027-9109
50 Division Street, Suite 400 Somerville, NJ 08876
Philadelphia Contributionship Ins Co
Phone: 1.877.438.7459 (Mon-Fri 8:30am – 8:00pm ET)
E-mail : service@phly.com
Plymouth Rock
Massachusetts
Automobile: 866-353-6292
Email: eservice@plymouthrock.com
Homeowners: 844-208-1935
Email: rockcare@plymouthrock.com
New Jersey
Phone: 877-725-6423
Email: nice@plymouthrock.com
New Jersey Teachers’ Insurance customers
Phone: 866-658-3224
Email: teachers@plymouthrock.com
Connecticut
Phone: 866-591-5545
Email: eservice@plymouthrock.com
Home insurance policy customers in Connecticut.
Phone: 844-208-1935
Email: rockcare@plymouthrock.com
New Hampshire
Auto insurance policy through Plymouth Rock in New Hampshire.
Phone: 800-979-6288
Email: eservice@plymouthrock.com
Umbrella insurance policy through Plymouth Rock in New Hampshire.
Phone: 800-979-6288
Email: eservice@plymouthrock.com
Home insurance policy customer in New Hampshire.
Phone: 844-208-1935
Email: homeinfo@plymouthrock.com
Pennsylvania
Phone: 877-725-6423
Email: nice@plymouthrock.com
Home insurance policy customer in Pennsylvania.
Phone: 844-208-1935
Email: homeinfo@plymouthrock.com
New York
Phone: 844-208-1932
Email: eservice@plymouthrock.com
Home insurance policy customer in New York.
Phone: 844-208-1935
Email: homeinfo@plymouthrock.com
POM Insurance
Call Us:
Monday – Friday 7:30 AM to 4:30 PM EST
(888) 451-1804
Mailing Address:
POM Insurance Company
PO Box 400
Branchville, New Jersey 07826
Progressive
1-888-671-4405
General Fax
1-877-280-5587
Corporate headquarters
The Progressive Corporation
6300 Wilson Mills Rd.
Mayfield Village, Ohio 44143
Safeco Insurance
Download Safeco Mobile App:
Apple | Google
Login to website: https://customer.safeco.com/accountmanager/Login/login.aspx?OriginalURL=/accountmanager/homepage
Policyholder support: 800-332-3226
Stillwater Insurance Group
Hours:
M-F: 8am-9pm EST
Saturday: 8am-3pm EST
Phone:
(855) 712-4092
Email: ins@stillwater.com
Business Insurance
Hours:
M-F: 8am-9pm EST
Saturday: 8am-3pm EST
Phone: (855) 712-4114
Email: ins@stillwater.com
Mailing Address
Correspondence and Payments:
PO Box 45126
Jacksonville, FL 32232-5126
Fax
General:
(866) 877-6355
Claims:
(800) 491-7683
Offices
Jacksonville, FL
6800 Southpoint Pkwy, Ste 700
Jacksonville, FL 32216
Omaha, NE
12500 I St, Ste 100
Omaha, NE 68137
Santa Barbara, CA
5385 Hollister Ave, Bldg 13
Santa Barbara, CA 93111
Selective Flood
As your licensed Selective insurance agent, we can assist you with coverage questions and advise you best about changes to your existing insurance policy. Please call as at 201-659-2403.
Flood Customers
Email: Floodcustomerservice@selective.com
Phone: 877-348-0552
Hours: 8am – 10pm (ET) M-FSELECTIVE FLOOD
Corporate Headquarters
Selective Insurance Company of America
40 Wantage Avenue
Branchville, NJ 07890-1000
Phone: 973-948-3000
Flood Operations
Selective Flood Operations
CN101, 40 Wantage Avenue
Branchville, NJ 07890
Phone: 877-348-0552
Heartland Region
Selective Insurance Company of America
900 E. 96th St., Suite 400
Indianapolis, IN 46240
Phone: 317-815-4300, 866-248-0850
Mid-Atlantic Region (PA Location)
Selective Insurance Company of America
1275 Glenlivet Drive, Suite 200
Allentown, PA 18106
Phone: 610-336-5800, 800-374-9656
Mid-Atlantic Region (MD Location)
Selective Insurance Company of America
6 North Park Drive, Suite 200
Hunt Valley, MD 21030-1842
Phone: 410-771-6500, 800-685-9656
New Jersey Region
Selective Insurance Company of America
200 Clocktower Drive, Suite 201
Hamilton, NJ 08690
Phone: 609-890-2200, 800-365-9656
Northeast Region
Selective Insurance Company of America
Attn: Northeast Region
40 Wantage Avenue
Branchville, NJ 07890-1000
Phone: 973-948-3000, 800-777-9656
Southern Region
Selective Insurance Company of America
3426 Toringdon Way, Ste. 200
Charlotte, NC 28277
Phone: 704-341-7474, 800-688-9656
Southwest Region
Selective Insurance Company of America
6263 North Scottsdale Road, Suite 310
Scottsdale, AZ 85250
Phone: 480-566-5000, 866-865-8790
Travelers / St Paul / Fidelity Ins. Co
1.800.842.5075
MyTravelers® Technical Assistance
1.877.754.0481
Roadside Assistance
1.800.252.4633
Select Option 3 in the phone menu
Customer Advocacy
Travelers is committed to providing you with the highest level of service. If you have questions or any concerns regarding the service you have received from us, please call 1.866.336.2077. Travelers is available 24/7.
Mail
Personal Insurance:
Travelers Personal Insurance
PO BOX 660307
Dallas, TX 75266-0307
Business Insurance:
Travelers CL Remittance Center
PO BOX 660317
Dallas, TX 75266-0317
Consumer Affairs (Complaints):
Travelers
Attn: Consumer Affairs
One Tower Square
Hartford, CT 06183
Wright Flood
To reach the Wright Flood processing center directly
Toll Free: 1.800.820.3242
Fax: 1.800.850.3299
Email: Customerservice@weareflood.com
By Mail: P.O. Box 33003, St. Petersburg, FL 33733-8003
Provide feedback to Wright Flood
Email Wright Flood at floodmarketing@weareflood.com. Please be sure to include your policy number, name, phone number and email address so we can get back in touch. Or contact Flood Marketing by phone at 1.866.373.5663.
