Filing an Insurance Claim
Muller Insurance is always there to help if you have questions or need to file a claim with your insurance company.
Below we have listed the contact information for every insurance company we represent.
Most routine claims are typically faster and easier to report online. However, if you’d like you can call us to report a claim at 201-659-2403. If it’s after hours, please contact the provider or go online to file a claim using the links below.
Licensed in 25 States
Learn More
AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
Phone: 888-239-3909 (Claims)
Workers’ Compensation for All States
Phone: 866-272-9267
Fax: 775-908-3724 or 877-669-9140
Email: Amtrustclaims@qrm-inc.com
Non-Workers’ Compensation
Phone: 866-272-9267
Fax: 877-207-3961
Email: anaclaimsreporting@amtrustgroup.com
Resources:
How to file a claim: https://amtrustfinancial.com/claims#fileaclaim
Learn More
Andover – Baystate & Merrimack
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
Claims Center: 1-800-225-0770
Learn More
Chubb / Great Northern / Vigilant & Federal
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
All Personal Lines Claims:
1-800-CLAIMS-0 (1-800-252-4670)
Business Claims – Legacy Chubb
Workers Compensation Claims: 1-800-699-9916
All Other Claims: 1-800-CLAIMS-0 (1-800-252-4670)
Business Claims – Legacy ACE
North America Commercial: 1-800-433-0385
Resources:
FAQs https://www.chubb.com/us-en/claims/faqs.aspx
Learn More
Cumberland Mutual Insurance Co.
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
To Report a Claim by Phone or Mail
Call us at: 1-800-232-6992
Mail us at:
Cumberland Mutual
633 Shiloh Pike, PO Box 556
Bridgeton, NJ 08302
For Emergency Claims Requiring Immediate Attention after Hours
Please contact a Cumberland Representative at 1-800-232-6992.
Learn More
Farmers Mutual of Salem
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
Claims Center: 1-800-498-0954 x-3
Learn More
Foremost Insurance Company Group
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
24/7 Claim Center: 800-527-3907
Learn More
Franklin Mutual Insurance Company / FMI Co
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
24/7 Claim Center: 800-336-3642 ( Option 2)
Learn More
Lemonade
How do I file a claim?
Easy! Just open the Lemonade app and hit the ‘Claim’ button. We will guide you through the rest of the short process there.
How will I get paid for a claim?
After you complete the claim report on the Lemonade app, you will be asked to enter your bank account information. Once your claim is approved, we’ll issue payment, minus the amount of your deductible, directly into your account.
Lemonade has a network of emergency response and repair partners enabling us to respond to just about any incident at just about any time.
For emergencies relating to your car, home, and property where you don’t have access to our app or website, you may call us at (844) 733-8666.
To reach Lemonade about a car claim via email you may contact us at carclaims@lemonade.com
Learn More
Liberty Mutual Insurance
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
Auto, general liability, property, umbrella, and workers compensation
Call us to report a property and casualty claim 24/7
Small Business Customers call 1-844-325-2467 (844-3-CLAIMS)
Mid/Large Business Customers call 1-800-362-0000
Learn More
Narragansett
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
Report a New Claim 24/7 at: 800-343-3375 | Option 2, then 1
New Claim e-mail to claimsmail@nbic.com
New Claim Fax to 401-721-0700
Learn More
National General
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
Claim Service Center: 1-800-325-1088
Email: claims@ngic.com
Learn More
Fitchburg Mutual / Norfolk & Dedham
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
24/7 Claim Center: 1-800-688-1825
Learn More
Philadelphia Contributionship Ins Co
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
To report a non-emergency claim:
By phone: 800-269-1409
By fax: 215-627-8871
By email: claims@1752.com
If a claims emergency occurs after regular office hours, call 800-269-1409, and you will be directed to Philadelphia’s “on call” claims adjuster who will be able to help you.
Learn More
Plymouth Rock
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
24/7 Claim Center: 1-844-346-1225
Resources:
Claim FAQs: https://www.plymouthrock.com/claims/faqs
Learn More
POM Insurance
Report a Claim by Phone
You can contact our claims team at (888) 451-1804
Report a Claim Online
Online claims reporting is quick and easy. Log into My Account.
Don’t have an Account? Register here.
Learn More
Progressive
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
24/7 Claim center: 1-800-776-4737
Learn More
Safeco Insurance
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
Website: https://fileaclaim.safeco.com/
Download Safeco Mobile App:
Apple | Google
Phone: 1-800-332-3226
Learn More
Stillwater Insurance Group
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
24/7 Claim Service Center: 1-800-220-1351
Claims email: lossnotices@stillwater.com
Learn More
Selective Flood
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
24/7 Claim Service Center: 1-866-455-9969
Flood Claims: 1-877-348-0552
Auto Glass Claims: 1-800-638-8961
Bond Claims: 1-800-777-9656, ext. 2176
Learn More
Travelers / St Paul / Fidelity Ins. Co
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
Claim Service Center: 1-800-252-4633
Call Travelers if you have significant property damage or if anyone was injured as a result of the accident. They’re here 24 hours a day, every day.
Learn More
Wright Flood
You can also start a new claim using any of the following:
- Use the link above to access the customer login as a policyholder or a guest.
- By text you can open a claim by texting the word claim to (727) 777-7066. Once the claim is filed you can text the word status to this same number for an update on claim payments on the way
- Without a policy number: call the claims department at 1 (800) 725-9472 and provide the insured name and address and date of your flood loss
Resources:
How to file a claim: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmChQdB5aDs&feature=youtu.be
