Insurance for Jewelry, Fine Arts and Other Collectibles in NJ, NY, CT, PA and Other States
Anything valuable enough to treasure for personal and/or financial reasons is worth insuring. At Muller Insurance we are here to help you get the coverage you need, in the amount you need. We offer policies through our insurance company associations that will cover all your treasures.
Appraisals aren’t always needed.
In some cases, for items valued at less than $50,000, appraisals aren’t needed. When appraisals are required for higher-priced items, we will help you through the process so that your valuables are fully protected for the right amount.
Jewelry is usually the first thing that comes to mind when securing extra insurance. And it certainly is a good idea, especially since standard homeowners or renters insurance is not likely to cover high-end pieces outright. But it is a good idea to think about what other valuables needed protected. These could include:
- Fine Arts (paintings, prints, sculptures, art deco/are nouveau lamps, fixtures, etc.)
- Antiques (furniture or other items)
- Fine Wine Collections
- Unique Collections (books, sports memorabilia, vintage posters, record alums, etc.)
Contact Muller Insurance to learn more about coverage throughout New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, and other states.

View Our Other Policies
Want help determining which coverage is best for your needs?
Call our advisors today.
201-659-2403
In a Hurry?
Fill out our Quick Quote.
Licensed in 26 States
One Trusted Agency

Get a QUICK QUOTE now
Additional Resources
Trends that Influence Art and Jewelry Insurance Policies
Some of the most common personal possessions that people have insured are jewelry and pieces of art. Besides their high dollar value, these items also often hold sentimental value that
Claims Happen—and Sometimes, They’re Bizarre
Insurance may seem boring to some—but we need it to protect our homes, cars, boats, property—and even our life and health. When we purchase insurance, we assume we’re protecting our
Why Your Unique Collection May Be at Risk without Insurance
Maybe it’s your grandmother’s thimble collection that was handed down to you, or perhaps you love the challenge of tracking down that rare card or record. No matter how it
Our Recent Reviews
- I had a great experience working with Tolga Sungu at Muller Insurance. He was proactive, responsive, and made setting up my condo insurance completely seamless. He even coordinated directly with my mortgage company to ensure the policy was uploaded and payments were handled properly. Highly recommend Tolga and Muller Insurance for anyone looking for efficient, top-tier service!read moreread lessI had a great experience working with Tolga to get renters insurance for my personal belongings and furniture. He was very kind and patient, answered all my questions, and explained the coverage clearly and in detail. What I appreciate most is that he continues to help whenever I have questions, even after I purchased the policy. I highly recommend him!read moreread less
- Hi, I called Mueller Insurance to renew my car insurance. I spoke to Tolga. I asked him about my policy renewal. He provided me the 6 months quote. I asked him if there was a better price. He did some research and emailed me a better quote. I was so happy. He saved me money. I quickly reviewed the policy and he processed my new insurance and canceled the existing one. I apprecitated his help. Thank you for a job well done. Carmenread moreread lessTolga saved the day! I needed home insurance a few days before a closing and he was able to get me multiple quotes, spent a ton of time talking to me and the mortgage company, including the day before and day of the closing to make sure that we had the right insurance as well as all of the documents we needed in order to close in time. Thank you so much, Tolga, for your amazing client service and thorough knowledge and communication skills!read moreread lessOutstanding customer service from start to finish! If you're like me, you know you need auto insurance but aren't exactly fluent in all the fine print, coverage options, and fine-tuning it takes to find the right policy. Tolga Sungu took the time to actually explain my options instead of just pushing a quote at me. He listened to what I needed, answered every question patiently, and made sure I understood exactly what I was buying and why.
It's rare to find that level of genuine, knowledgeable service these days. If you're looking for an auto insurance agent who treats you like a person and not just a policy number, ask for Tolga Sungu. Highly recommend!read moreread less - Helen Mbiad has been my agent for almost 20 years, and to say she knows how to serve the public would be an understatement. Kind, courteous, leads with integrity. Always looking to see what's most important to me in different policies and then makes it happen. A huge asset to Muller Insurance and to the public as well.read moreread lessHad an absolute great experience working with Helen. She was so professional, kind, and caring. Helen was extremely attentive, reachable, and prompt. I am so happy that I found this agency, and even more-so Helen. Looking forward to working with her, and this agency, for years to come.read moreread lessMueller's Insurance is top-notch. I recently used them for my own home policy and helped my mother navigate her renewal process, and their team is consistently responsive, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. A special shoutout to Tolga—he was incredibly patient, took the time to listen, and helped us carefully tailor our coverage to fit our specific needs without any pressure. It is rare to find someone who genuinely cares about getting you the right policy rather than just making a sale. Tolga's professionalism and dedication to his clients are truly unmatched! Thank you Tolga -Devread moreread less
- Exceptional and Proactive Professional Service
I highly recommend Esmeralda at Muller Insurance for her outstanding support following the sale of my condo at Hoboken NJ. She proactively contacted me to initiate the policy cancellation process, which I had otherwise overlooked.
Esmeralda demonstrated extensive professional knowledge and patience while guiding me through the cancellation and arranging for my refund to be issued by check. Furthermore, she provided a helpful reminder regarding the proper management of my escrow account during this transition.
Her responsiveness and thorough approach made this experience straightforward and seamless. I value her dependable service and would recommend her to anyone seeking a reliable insurance agent.read moreread lessI’ve had the pleasure of working with Rosemarie for over a decade as she has assisted me with obtaining coverage for several condos and single family homes and also filing a claim when my condo flooded. Highly recommend her as she is professional, very experienced and very responsive.read moreread lessI never write reviews - but I have to say that working with Tolga was one of the best experiences I have had with customer service. He was attentive, willing to work with my unique schedule, supportive in working through my policy, and made it SO easy to transfer my insurance across states. Getting a new policy sucks and takes so much time, it doesn't need to be painful working with him.read moreread less - I have worked with Muller, and specifically Helen Mbiad, for the past 17 years since buying our home in Hoboken. Helen personifies service. She is affable, knowledgeable, highly responsive - exactly the kind of person you want in your corner. Insurance can be difficult and stressful to think through, but Helen makes it approachable. A masterclass in service that others would do well to replicate.Keep up the great work!read moreread lessThe best experience I have ever had dealing with both auto and home insurance. My super insurance agent "Tolga " was excellent, very informative, extremely knowledgeable, and made this process simple and easy to understand. Highly recommend him without a doubt.read moreread lessI recently worked with Tolga from Muller Insurance to obtain auto insurance and Tolga did a great job! He was very responsive and helpful. He was able to find an affordable auto policy and helped me bundle my other insurance as well. Highly recommend and great to support a local business.read moreread less
- I worked with Terri Lengen to find a good option for my condo insurance, and she was extremely helpful. She was very responsive and effective, and helped me find a policy with better coverage at a much better price than the alternatives I already had or I was considering. Highly recommended!read moreread lessWe have worked with Terri Lengen now for almost two decades, she has been professional, responsive, and always finds us the best coverage for new purchases or renewals. She is our “go to” person for all our needs in New Jersey and Pennsylvania - thanks as always Terri!read moreread lessToday Tolga Sungu helped me and provided excellent service. After a bit of back and forth, he helped me get a new quote for my apartment insurance, offering me a great rate and excellent benefits. He answered all my questions and helped me understand the process for my apartment insurance. He's very easy to reach, whether by email or phone, and he was always on top of helping me. Thank you so much, Tolga!read moreread lessI have worked with Muller for years for commercial property our insurance and flood insurance needs. Terri has been great to work with, very helpful and responsive, and always available to answer my questions in a timely manner. I would recommend Terri and Muller Insurance to anybody for whom great customer service is a must!read moreread lessI have been working with Terri Lengen for over 5 years now, and she is the only reason I am sticking with Muller Insurance for all my insurance needs. Muller was first recommended to me when I bought my apartment in Jersey City, but I went back to Terri for homeowner's insurance when I bought my house four years later. She always responds immediately via email, is reachable by phone with 1 hop (which in today's world of bots and apps and IVR is premium white-glove service), and so very personable. Through my challenges with the bank pushing out closing multiple times and requiring proof in all shapes and forms, Terri has stood with me. I'm so grateful to her. When I called her, she proactively checked with me whether I was now renting my apartment, and recommended correctly that I now needed to update it to a rental, which I did promptly. Today, I called her to report a water leak and she pulled up the service line coverage, confirmed it was eligible to claim and helped me file it. This is exactly the kind of 5-star customer service that I want from my insurance agent, and I have no qualms posting this review on Google or any other website for Terri and Muller Insurance.read moreread less






