Making a Payment
Muller Insurance is always there to help if you have questions or need to make a payment with your insurance company.
Below we have listed the contact information for every insurance company we represent.
Licensed in Over 30 States
Learn More
Andover – Baystate & Merrimack
Log in to the policyholder portal to pay your bill, view your payment history, and more.
Learn More
Chubb / Great Northern / Vigilant & Federal
Pay by Phone or Mail:
16 digit bill account numbers:
Phone: 800-682-4822
Mail:
Chubb Personal Risk Services
PO Box 7247-0180
Philadelphia, PA 19170-0180
9 digit bill account numbers:
Phone: 800-444-6161
Mail:
Chubb Personal Risk Services
PO Box 94836
Cleveland, OH 44101-4836
Please include your account number on your check
Learn More
Cumberland Mutual Insurance Co.
Please dial 1-800-232-6992 and press 1. Available Monday – Friday
8:00am to 5:00pm.
Mail your check and remittance stub
Cumberland Mutual
P.O. Box 596
Bridgeton, NJ 08302
Useful tips when submitting your payment by mail:
- Use the return envelope provided with your bill
- Be sure to put your policy number on your check
- Do not enclose cash
- Do not staple your check or money order
- Be sure to sign your check
Pay in Person
You can also submit a payment at your agent’s office, or at:
Cumberland Mutual
633 Shiloh Pike
Bridgeton, NJ 08302
Learn More
Foremost Insurance Company Group
Monday – Friday 9AM to 8PM ET
Automated Phone System: 24/7
Learn More
Liberty Mutual Insurance
Small Business Customers (<1,000 Employees)
Select MyBusinessOnline to log in.
Contact Billing:
Phone: 1-866-290-2920
Email
Mailing Address for Payments
Liberty Mutual Insurance
P.O. Box 2839
New York, NY 10116-2839
Midsize/Large Business Customers
Select our online portal to log in or obtain technical assistance. Account management for customers, agents and brokers.
Contact Billing:
Phone: 1-800-320-7582
Mailing Address for Payments
Liberty Mutual Insurance
P.O. Box 1449
New York, NY 10116-1449
Learn More
Narragansett
Pay by Mail:
Please make checks payable to “Narragansett Bay Insurance Company”, include your policy number on the memo line of your check, and mail to the address associated with your policy number format:
My Policy number contains only 8 numbers:
Example – 12345678
Policyholders:
Narragansett Bay Insurance Company
PO Box 415875
Boston, MA 02241-5875
Mortgage companies:
Narragansett Bay Insurance Company
PO Box 415880
Boston, MA 02241-5880
Overnight payment processing:
Bank of America Lockbox Services
Narragansett Bay Insurance #415880
MA5-527-02-07
2 Morrissey Blvd.
Dorchester, MA 02125
My policy number contains a series of 14 numbers and letters:
Example – 12H3-45678912-01
Policyholders:
Narragansett Bay Insurance Company
PO Box 419305
Boston, MA 02241-9305
Mortgage companies:
Narragansett Bay Insurance Company
PO Box 419311
Boston, MA 02241-9311
Overnight payment processing:
Bank of America Lockbox Services
Narragansett Bay Insurance #419311
MA5-527-02-07
2 Morrissey Blvd.
Dorchester, MA 02125
My policy number contains my state abbreviation and 7 numbers:
Example – NYH1234567 or NYH1234567-01
Policyholders & Mortgage Companies:
Narragansett Bay Insurance Company
c/o Bank of Tampa
PO Box 31317
Tampa, FL 33631
Overnight payment processing:
Narragansett Bay Insurance Company
c/o Bank of Tampa Remittance Dept.
4503 Woodland Corporate Blvd. Ste. 100
Tampa, FL 33614
Learn More
Fitchburg Mutual / Norfolk & Dedham
- Available for AR, MA, NH, NJ, NY policies.
- They accept Discover, MasterCard, or Visa, as well as your checking or savings account.
- Please have your installment notice and payment method ready.
- Policy must be active and on 4 Pay, 10 Pay or Full Pay plan (EDP policies not eligible).
- Payments may not be less than installment amount due or greater than remaining balance due.
- Payments will be posted to your account within 24 hours. For each payment, you will receive a confirmation number followed by an email confirmation for your records.
- If your policy is scheduled to cancel within the next two days, please notify us and provide us with your payment confirmation number.
Pay By Check
- Mail N&D your payment along with the payment stub using the return envelope provided and send to:
Norfolk & Dedham Group
P.O. Box 4104
Woburn, MA 01888-4104 - Overnight payments to the Dedham office at:
Norfolk & Dedham Group
222 Ames Street
Dedham, MA 02026
Learn More
Philadelphia Contributionship Ins Co
Pay by Phone: 1-888-627-1752
Pay by Mail:
Mail your check or money order to:
The Philadelphia Contributionship
P.O. Box 100
Philadelphia, PA 19105
Pay by Check or Money Order in Person (Cash Payments are not Accepted.)
Pay in person at:
210 South Fourth Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Learn More
Plymouth Rock
Send your check and payment stub in the envelope Plymouth Rock provided or, print out a copy of your bill from the Documents page in your online account and mail it to Plymouth Rock. Don’t forget to write your policy number on the check! Please allow at least 5 business days for your payment to process.
Learn More
Learn More
Stillwater Insurance Group
Pay by Phone: (855) 712-4092
Pay by Mail:
PO Box 45126
Jacksonville, FL 32232-5126
Learn More
Selective Flood
Pay by Phone:
(888) 974-7400 (Home, Auto & Business Policy Customers)
(877) 348-0552 (Flood Insurance)
Pay by Mail:
Home, Auto & Business Policy Customers
Regular Mail
Selective
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
Overnight / Express Mail
Selective
500 Ross Street Room 154-0470
Pittsburgh, PA 15262-0001
Attn: Box 371468
Flood Insurance
Send by regular mail
Selective – Flood
PO Box 782747
Philadelphia, PA 19178-2747
Send by overnight mail
Selective – Lockbox #2747
MAC Y1372-045
401 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Learn More
Travelers / St Paul / Fidelity Ins. Co
For Personal Insurance policies, mail payments to:
Travelers Personal Insurance
P. O. Box 660307
Dallas, TX 75266-0307
Note: Please write your account or policy number on your check or money order.
For overnight delivery, mail payments to:
Travelers Insurance
Attn: Lockbox Operations Box 660307
2701 East Grauwyler Rd., Bldg 1
Irving, TX 75061
For Claim Subrogation (FedEx only), mail payments to:
Travelers Insurance
Attn: Lockbox Operations 660339
2701 East Grauwyler Rd., BLDG 1
Irving, TX 75061
Pay by phone
Call the phone number located in the upper right-hand corner of your Travelers bill and follow the prompts provided.
You can use your phone to:
- Check your payment due
- Pay your Travelers bill
- Have your payment posted to your account the next business day
- Check the last payment received
- Check your unpaid balance
- Find information about cancellations, changes, refunds and returned checks using our Automated Billing and Payment Services
Learn More
Wright Flood
Pay by US Mail or by overnight delivery
Payment Address
P.O. Box 33003, St. Petersburg, FL 33733-8003
Overnight Payment Address
801 94th Ave North, Ste 110, St. Petersburg, FL 33702